← Back to Wars

Sitting Ducks vs Elite Trolls...

CWL R2
30v30
64 - 58
Victory

War Analysis

18 bases not 3-starred

Executive Summary

Sitting Ducks secured a 64-58 victory over Elite Trolls... despite leaving 18 bases un-3-starred and missing two attacks. The win was anchored by heroic fresh 3-stars from BOOM!, igo, and AlbaMana, alongside crucial mismatch 2-stars from lower Town Halls hitting up. However, a complete collapse in the middle section and a total lack of cleanup coordination left significant stars on the board.

Section Performance

top #1-10 9 players
2.2 avg stars
20/27 possible stars
middle #11-20 6 players
1.5 avg stars
9/18 possible stars
bottom #21-30 9 players
2.1 avg stars
19/27 possible stars

Un-3-starred Bases (16 bases attacked but not cleared)

# Defender TH Attacks Best Attackers
1 AsheNBraKe2 18 1 2* SenorGato (TH18): 2*
2 WarPig!! 18 1 1* who am i (TH18): 1*
4 TonyD22 18 1 2* .Duck (TH18): 2*
8 ELITE www.@com 18 1 1* C-Dub (TH18): 1*
10 anthonythegamr2 18 1 2* Loutony (TH18): 2*
12 Vuuduu 18 1 2* Anthony (TH18): 2*
16 Gladiator 18 1 2* Ataraxy Queen (TH18): 2*
18 Anthonythegamer 18 1 2* ManaAlba (TH18): 2*
19 Mike's A Troll1 18 1 2* SlapShot (TH17): 2*
21 Ryan 18 1 2* Shifty (TH17): 2*
23 CHIEF RIO 18 1 1* PRO⚡️EMPEROR (TH18): 1*
26 Ello Asty 18 1 1* Tgeland 2.0 (TH17): 1*
27 CnF 18 1 2* Dark Sparks (TH17): 2*
29 Vuuduu2 18 1 2* Ritz (TH17): 2*
33 krynn 17 1 2* TopShelf (TH17): 2*
39 Богатырь 18 1 2* DeevesMcQueen (TH16): 2*

Missed Attacks (2)

BigDaddyDyl #15 TH18 0/1
Madara #18 TH18 0/1

MVPs (ranked by net stars + clutch bonus)

BOOM!
#7 TH18
3 net stars
3 raw stars — #7: 3* 100%
igo
#22 TH17
3 net stars
3 raw stars — #20: 3* 100%
AlbaMana
#26 TH17
3 net stars
3 raw stars — #24: 3* 100%

Root Cause Analysis

The victory was salvaged by top and bottom section carries, combined with lower Town Halls like Ritz and Shifty successfully securing high-percentage 2-stars against TH18 mismatches. However, the clan's offensive coordination was highly flawed: the middle section (#11-20) completely collapsed, yielding only 9 stars, and zero cleanup attacks were organized. Because BigDaddyDyl and Madara missed their attacks, 18 bases received exactly one attack, leaving untouched bases (#15, #17) and multiple 1-star disasters (from who am i and C-Dub) unresolved.

What-If Scenarios

If BigDaddyDyl and Madara had used their missed attacks to clean up the 98% and 99% 2-stars on bases #4, #12, or #29, the clan would have easily broken 70 stars. Conversely, if TH17s/TH16s like Ritz (99% on #29) and Shifty (93% on #21) hadn't secured clutch 2-stars against TH18 mismatches, the middle section's collapse could have cost the clan the war.

Actionable Takeaways

  • ‣ Implement a strict cleanup protocol: 18 bases received exactly one attack, leaving high-percentage 2-stars like Anthony's 98% on #12 and .Duck's 98% on #4 stranded.
  • ‣ Address the middle section's (#11-20) collapse, which produced only 9 stars from 6 players, to ensure better base identification and attack planning.
  • ‣ Hold BigDaddyDyl and Madara accountable for their missed attacks, which could have easily cleared untouched bases #15 and #17 or fixed 1-star blunders.
  • ‣ Continue leveraging skilled lower Town Halls like Ritz, Shifty, and DeevesMcQueen for mismatch 2-stars against top bases, as their 87%+ hits on TH18s provided critical cover for the middle's failures.

Member Performance

★ Atk 1
# Player TH Attacks Stars Targets
1 SenorGato 18 1/1
74% ★★★
#1 TH18
2 who am i 18 1/1
85% ★★★
#2 TH18
3 LilWeezyAna 18 1/1
★★★
#3 TH18
4 .Duck 18 1/1
98% ★★★
#4 TH18
5 The Godfather 18 1/1
★★★
#5 TH18
7 BOOM! 18 1/1
★★★
#7 TH18
8 C-Dub 18 1/1
86% ★★★
#8 TH18
9 Loutony 18 1/1
60% ★★★
#10 TH18
10 Reptar 18 1/1
★★★
#11 TH18
11 Anthony 18 1/1
98% ★★★
#12 TH18
12 Smooth Criminal 18 1/1
★★★
#14 TH18
15 BigDaddyDyl 18 0/1 no attacks
17 Ataraxy Queen 18 1/1
77% ★★★
#16 TH18
18 Madara 18 0/1 no attacks
19 ManaAlba 18 1/1
71% ★★★
#18 TH18
21 SlapShot 17 1/1
92% ★★★
#19 TH18
22 igo 17 1/1
★★★
#20 TH18
23 Shifty 17 1/1
93% ★★★
#21 TH18
24 WARLORD 17 1/1
★★★
#22 TH18
25 PRO⚡️EMPEROR 18 1/1
82% ★★★
#23 TH18
26 AlbaMana 17 1/1
★★★
#24 TH18
27 Tgeland 2.0 17 1/1
79% ★★★
#26 TH18
28 Dark Sparks 17 1/1
90% ★★★
#27 TH18
30 Ritz 17 1/1
99% ★★★
#29 TH18
31 MJ Belim 17 1/1
★★★
#31 TH18
34 TopShelf 17 1/1
89% ★★★
#33 TH17
35 Shady 17 1/1
★★★
#34 TH18
36 ⚜Who Dat⚜ 16 1/1
★★★
#37 TH18
40 DeevesMcQueen 16 1/1
87% ★★★
#39 TH18
41 KingSlapShot 17 1/1
★★★
#41 TH17

Attacks

Order Attacker TH Atk# Defender Def# Def TH Stars Destruction
2 SenorGato 18 1st AsheNBraKe2 1 18 ★ ★ ★ 74%
4 BOOM! 18 1st Big T 7 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
14 igo 17 1st MR. E 20 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
15 AlbaMana 17 1st mr.wood 24 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
16 ManaAlba 18 1st Anthonythegamer 18 18 ★ ★ ★ 71%
17 MJ Belim 17 1st Greenmac75 31 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
19 The Godfather 18 1st RedEyedMan 5 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
20 WARLORD 17 1st george0213 22 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
21 Loutony 18 1st anthonythegamr2 10 18 ★ ★ ★ 60%
22 Shady 17 1st gavin 34 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
23 Shifty 17 1st Ryan 21 18 ★ ★ ★ 93%
24 Ataraxy Queen 18 1st Gladiator 16 18 ★ ★ ★ 77%
25 Reptar 18 1st Tommyboy 11 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
26 LilWeezyAna 18 1st Fire and Ice 3 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
30 Smooth Criminal 18 1st CF2 14 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
32 PRO⚡️EMPEROR 18 1st CHIEF RIO 23 18 ★ ★ ★ 82%
35 ⚜Who Dat⚜ 16 1st rma75 37 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
38 Tgeland 2.0 17 1st Ello Asty 26 18 ★ ★ ★ 79%
39 Anthony 18 1st Vuuduu 12 18 ★ ★ ★ 98%
40 DeevesMcQueen 16 1st Богатырь 39 18 ★ ★ ★ 87%
41 SlapShot 17 1st Mike's A Troll1 19 18 ★ ★ ★ 92%
42 KingSlapShot 17 1st Jake BruiserJK 41 17 ★ ★ ★ 100%
44 who am i 18 1st WarPig!! 2 18 ★ ★ ★ 85%
45 TopShelf 17 1st krynn 33 17 ★ ★ ★ 89%
49 .Duck 18 1st TonyD22 4 18 ★ ★ ★ 98%
50 C-Dub 18 1st ELITE www.@com 8 18 ★ ★ ★ 86%
54 Ritz 17 1st Vuuduu2 29 18 ★ ★ ★ 99%
55 Dark Sparks 17 1st CnF 27 18 ★ ★ ★ 90%