Sitting Ducks vs One Piece

30v30

89 - 90

Defeat

War Analysis

1 base not 3-starred

Executive Summary

We suffered a heartbreaking 89-90 loss to One Piece, falling short by exactly 1 star and 0.1% destruction (99.9% vs 100.0%). The defeat was entirely preventable, caused by 4 unused attacks and a massive 6-attack pileup on Base #14 that neutralized a heroic carry job by the middle and bottom sections.

Section Performance

top #1-10 10 players

4.0 avg stars

40/60 possible stars

bottom #21-30 10 players

4.6 avg stars

46/60 possible stars

middle #11-20 10 players

4.6 avg stars

46/60 possible stars

Un-3-starred Bases (1 bases attacked but not cleared)

#	Defender	TH	Attacks	Best	Attackers
14	LucaszBR⚡NDD	18	6	2*	Thor (TH18): 2, Slaughterhouse (TH18): 2, Shifty (TH18): 1, who am i (TH18): 2, The Godfather (TH18): 1, Reptar (TH18): 1

Pileup Bases

#7 ¥ PRESIDENT ¥™ received 5 attacks (9% of total) — 3-starred

#14 LucaszBR⚡NDD received 6 attacks (11% of total) — best 2*

#15 WOLFFGG received 4 attacks (7% of total) — 3-starred

#16 Fragmentado received 5 attacks (9% of total) — 3-starred

#17 YURI received 4 attacks (7% of total) — 3-starred

Under-Performers

The Godfather #4 TH18 1* vs 4.0 avg

nirvana #9 TH18 2* vs 4.0 avg

Anika #15 TH18 3* vs 4.6 avg

MEGHA #27 TH16 3* vs 4.6 avg

Missed Attacks (4)

The Godfather #4 TH18 1/2

MEGHA #27 TH16 1/2

DEADLYFEET #28 TH14 0/2

MVPs (ranked by net stars + clutch bonus)

BOOM!

#5 TH18

4 net stars +4 clutch

6 raw stars — #5: 3* 100%, #7: 3* 100%

Dr Haram

#29 TH16

6 net stars

6 raw stars — #28: 3* 100%, #27: 3* 100%

Dr Halal

#25 TH17

6 net stars

6 raw stars — #25: 3* 100%, #24: 3* 100%

Clutch Attacks (3-starred after 2+ prior failed attempts)

BOOM! #5 TH18 3-starred #7 ¥ PRESIDENT ¥™

After 4 failed attempts: Thor (1*), nirvana (1*), Gus Vats (2*), Anthony (2*)

Shifty #13 TH18 3-starred #15 WOLFFGG

After 3 failed attempts: Anika (2*), AlbaMana (2*), ManaAlba (2*)

ManaAlba #11 TH18 3-starred #16 Fragmentado

After 4 failed attempts: Dark Sparks (2*), ⚜Who Dat⚜ (1*), TopShelf (2*), AlbaMana (2*)

TopShelf #20 TH18 3-starred #17 YURI

After 3 failed attempts: igo (2*), Anika (1*), Loki (1*)

Root Cause Analysis

The loss stems from a cascading failure in the top section (averaging just 4.0 stars) and poor late-war attack management. The Godfather (1 star) and nirvana (2 stars) struggled heavily, forcing the clan into multiple TH18 pileups. While clutch hits broke pileups on #7, #15, #16, and #17, we wasted 4 late attacks trying to top Slaughterhouse's 97% 2-star on #14. Ultimately, leaving 4 attacks on the board—including one from The Godfather and two from DEADLYFEET—left the crucial final star on the table.

What-If Scenarios

If any of the 4 missed attacks (from The Godfather, MEGHA, or DEADLYFEET) had been used to finally clear Base #14, we would have secured the final star and won the war. Conversely, if BOOM!, Shifty, ManaAlba, and TopShelf hadn't delivered massive clutch 3-stars on bases #7, #15, #16, and #17 after multiple previous failures, we would have lost by 5+ stars.

Actionable Takeaways

‣ Mandate 100% attack usage; the missed attacks from The Godfather, MEGHA, and DEADLYFEET were the literal difference between a win and a loss.
‣ Stop sending lower Town Halls like Loki and ⚜Who Dat⚜ (TH17) to hit TH18 pileup bases (#16, #17), as these 1-star mismatch attacks waste attempts that should be used for cleanup.
‣ Top section attackers, specifically The Godfather and nirvana, need to review TH18 attack strategies to relieve the immense pressure they placed on the middle and bottom rosters.
‣ Implement a hard stop on pileups like Base #14; after Slaughterhouse hit 97%, subsequent attackers (Shifty, who am i, The Godfather, Reptar) should have been redirected unless they had a guaranteed plan to secure the 3-star.

♻ Cleanup Attacks (2)

Gus Vats (#19) cleaned up #29 — mirror handled, 10 positions below

ManaAlba (#11) cleaned up #16 — mirror handled, 5 positions below

Member Performance

♻ Cleanup attack| ★ Atk 1 ★ Atk 2

#	Player	TH	Attacks	Stars	Targets
1	SenorGato	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★ 90%	#2 TH18 \| #3 TH18
2	who am i	18	2/2	87% ★★★ \| ★★★	#14 TH18 \| ▼ #30 TH9
3	LilWeezyAna	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#3 TH18 \| #4 TH18
4	The Godfather	18	1/2	97% ★★★ \| missed	#14 TH18
5	BOOM!	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#5 TH18 \| #7 TH18
6	Thor	18	2/2	65% ★★★ \| ★★★ 81%	#7 TH18 \| #14 TH18
7	Anthony	18	2/2	88% ★★★ \| ★★★	#7 TH18 \| #9 TH18
8	Reptar	18	2/2	95% ★★★ \| ★★★ 79%	#14 TH18 \| #1 TH18
9	nirvana	18	2/2	93% ★★★ \| ★★★ 88%	#6 TH18 \| #7 TH18
10	nut	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★ 92%	#10 TH18 \| #9 TH18
11	ManaAlba	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★ 66%	♻ #16 TH18 \| #15 TH18
12	WARLORD	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#12 TH18 \| #13 TH18
13	Shifty	18	2/2	94% ★★★ \| ★★★	#14 TH18 \| #15 TH18
14	Slaughterhouse	18	2/2	77% ★★★ \| ★★★ 97%	#13 TH18 \| #14 TH18
15	Anika	18	2/2	96% ★★★ \| ★★★ 87%	#15 TH18 \| #17 TH18
16	Dark Sparks	18	2/2	96% ★★★ \| ★★★	#16 TH18 \| #18 TH18
17	igo	18	2/2	81% ★★★ \| ★★★	#17 TH18 \| #1 TH18
18	AlbaMana	18	2/2	72% ★★★ \| ★★★ 79%	#16 TH18 \| #15 TH18
19	Gus Vats	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★ 85%	♻ #29 TH10 \| #7 TH18
20	TopShelf	18	2/2	85% ★★★ \| ★★★	#16 TH18 \| #17 TH18
21	SlapShot	18	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#21 TH17 \| #20 TH18
22	KingSlapShot	17	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#22 TH17 \| #23 TH17
23	Loki	17	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★ 89%	#19 TH18 \| #17 TH18
24	Shady	17	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#8 TH18 \| #11 TH18
25	Dr Halal	17	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#25 TH18 \| #24 TH17
26	⚜Who Dat⚜	17	2/2	64% ★★★ \| ★★★	#16 TH18 \| #6 TH18
27	MEGHA	16	1/2	★★★ \| missed	#26 TH16
28	DEADLYFEET	14	0/2	no attacks
29	Dr Haram	16	2/2	★★★ \| ★★★	#28 TH15 \| #27 TH16
30	Poropo6	10	2/2	90% ★★★ \| ★★★	#29 TH10 \| #30 TH9

Attacks

Order	Attacker	TH	Atk#	Defender	Def#	Def TH	Stars	Destruction
1	Poropo6	10	1st	Fragmentado V	29	10	★ ★ ★	90%
3	igo	18	1st	YURI	17	18	★ ★ ★	81%
5	igo	18	2nd	Bob Boladão	1	18	★ ★ ★	100%
7	Poropo6	10	2nd	⚡Mihawk™ Th6	30	9	★ ★ ★	100%
15	Anika	18	1st	WOLFFGG	15	18	★ ★ ★	96%
16	Anika	18	2nd	YURI	17	18	★ ★ ★	87%
21	nut	18	1st	Smoke Tank	10	18	★ ★ ★	100%
22	nut	18	2nd	DEMOLITOR	9	18	★ ★ ★	92%
25	SenorGato	18	1st	CanalMasterKing	2	18	★ ★ ★	100%
27	SenorGato	18	2nd	SILVA !❄️	3	18	★ ★ ★	90%
29	BOOM!	18	1st	peido	5	18	★ ★ ★	100%
30	LilWeezyAna	18	1st	SILVA !❄️	3	18	★ ★ ★	100%
31	LilWeezyAna	18	2nd	traste	4	18	★ ★ ★	100%
33	Dr Haram	16	1st	L.S.B.	28	15	★ ★ ★	100%
34	Dr Haram	16	2nd	『KNH』Indra火	27	16	★ ★ ★	100%
35	Dr Halal	17	1st	Unknown ♋️	25	18	★ ★ ★	100%
36	Dr Halal	17	2nd	Schmidt	24	17	★ ★ ★	100%
37	WARLORD	18	1st	MARRECADA NELAS	12	18	★ ★ ★	100%
38	KingSlapShot	17	1st	Fragmentado Jr	22	17	★ ★ ★	100%
39	SlapShot	18	1st	Baltazaar	21	17	★ ★ ★	100%
40	KingSlapShot	17	2nd	Sheik	23	17	★ ★ ★	100%
41	SlapShot	18	2nd	Yusuke Urameshi	20	18	★ ★ ★	100%
47	MEGHA	16	1st	Fragmentado \|\|\|	26	16	★ ★ ★	100%
49	Dark Sparks	18	1st	Fragmentado	16	18	★ ★ ★	96%
50	Dark Sparks	18	2nd	JONY^_^	18	18	★ ★ ★	100%
51	Loki	17	1st	JR_SANGALLI-WAR	19	18	★ ★ ★	100%
52	Loki	17	2nd	YURI	17	18	★ ★ ★	89%
53	Thor	18	1st	¥ PRESIDENT ¥™	7	18	★ ★ ★	65%
54	Thor	18	2nd	LucaszBR⚡NDD	14	18	★ ★ ★	81%
57	nirvana	18	1st	⚡Mihawk™	6	18	★ ★ ★	93%
58	Shady	17	1st	Staffa	8	18	★ ★ ★	100%
59	Shady	17	2nd	ASURA	11	18	★ ★ ★	100%
62	nirvana	18	2nd	¥ PRESIDENT ¥™	7	18	★ ★ ★	88%
64	Slaughterhouse	18	1st	Kurama Youko	13	18	★ ★ ★	77%
65	Slaughterhouse	18	2nd	LucaszBR⚡NDD	14	18	★ ★ ★	97%
66	Gus Vats ♻	18	1st	Fragmentado V	29	10	★ ★ ★	100%
67	Gus Vats	18	2nd	¥ PRESIDENT ¥™	7	18	★ ★ ★	85%
68	Anthony	18	1st	¥ PRESIDENT ¥™	7	18	★ ★ ★	88%
69	Anthony	18	2nd	DEMOLITOR	9	18	★ ★ ★	100%
70	⚜Who Dat⚜	17	1st	Fragmentado	16	18	★ ★ ★	64%
71	⚜Who Dat⚜	17	2nd	⚡Mihawk™	6	18	★ ★ ★	100%
75	TopShelf	18	1st	Fragmentado	16	18	★ ★ ★	85%
76	TopShelf	18	2nd	YURI	17	18	★ ★ ★	100%
77	BOOM!	18	2nd	¥ PRESIDENT ¥™	7	18	★ ★ ★	100%
78	AlbaMana	18	1st	Fragmentado	16	18	★ ★ ★	72%
79	ManaAlba ♻	18	1st	Fragmentado	16	18	★ ★ ★	100%
80	AlbaMana	18	2nd	WOLFFGG	15	18	★ ★ ★	79%
81	ManaAlba	18	2nd	WOLFFGG	15	18	★ ★ ★	66%
82	WARLORD	18	2nd	Kurama Youko	13	18	★ ★ ★	100%
87	Shifty	18	1st	LucaszBR⚡NDD	14	18	★ ★ ★	94%
88	Shifty	18	2nd	WOLFFGG	15	18	★ ★ ★	100%
94	who am i	18	1st	LucaszBR⚡NDD	14	18	★ ★ ★	87%
95	The Godfather	18	1st	LucaszBR⚡NDD	14	18	★ ★ ★	97%
98	Reptar	18	1st	LucaszBR⚡NDD	14	18	★ ★ ★	95%
99	Reptar	18	2nd	Bob Boladão	1	18	★ ★ ★	79%
102	who am i	18	2nd	⚡Mihawk™ Th6	30	9	★ ★ ★	100%

Still there?