Sitting Ducks vs NF❄️Northguard
30v30
87
-
90
Defeat
War Analysis
3 bases not 3-starredExecutive Summary
Sitting Ducks lost a heartbreaking 87-90 war to NF❄️Northguard despite a heroic 5.0 star average from the bottom section. The 3-star deficit was directly caused by severe inefficiency at the top of the map, highlighted by a massive 7-attack pileup on Base #15 and a crucial missed attack.
Section Performance
top #1-10
10 players
4.0 avg stars
40/60 possible stars
bottom #21-30
10 players
5.0 avg stars
50/60 possible stars
middle #11-20
10 players
4.5 avg stars
45/60 possible stars
Un-3-starred Bases (3 bases attacked but not cleared)
| # | Defender | TH | Attacks | Best | Attackers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 | ProbablyS1M0N | 18 | 3 | 2* | nirvana (TH18): 1*, Anika (TH18): 2*, Ataraxy Queen (TH18): 1* |
| 13 | Muffin | 18 | 4 | 2* | Slaughterhouse (TH18): 2*, Thor (TH18): 1*, Dr Haram (TH16): 1*, ManaAlba (TH18): 2* |
| 15 | ChuubChuup | 18 | 7 | 2* | Shady (TH17): 2*, Gus Vats (TH18): 2*, Loki (TH17): 2*, TopShelf (TH18): 2*, Thor (TH18): 1*, Dr Haram (TH16): 2*, ManaAlba (TH18): 2* |
Pileup Bases
#3 Dr.Med.DenRasen
received 3 attacks
(5% of total)
— 3-starred
#5 LubiAs
received 4 attacks
(7% of total)
— 3-starred
#9 ProbablyS1M0N
received 3 attacks
(5% of total)
— best 2*
#10 leon
received 3 attacks
(5% of total)
— 3-starred
#13 Muffin
received 4 attacks
(7% of total)
— best 2*
#15 ChuubChuup
received 7 attacks
(12% of total)
— best 2*
#16 Loubex
received 3 attacks
(5% of total)
— 3-starred
#20 ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃
received 6 attacks
(10% of total)
— 3-starred
Under-Performers
Thor #6 TH18
2* vs 4.0 avg
Anthony #8 TH18
2* vs 4.0 avg
Slaughterhouse #14 TH18
2* vs 4.5 avg
Dr Haram #30 TH16
3* vs 5.0 avg
Missed Attacks (1)
Anthony #8 TH18
1/2
MVPs (ranked by net stars + clutch bonus)
Reptar
#7 TH18
6 net stars
6 raw stars —
#7: 3* 100%, #6: 3* 100%
igo
#19 TH18
6 net stars
6 raw stars —
#19: 3* 100%, #18: 3* 100%
KingSlapShot
#23 TH17
6 net stars
6 raw stars —
#23: 3* 100%, #24: 3* 100%
Clutch Attacks (3-starred after 2+ prior failed attempts)
Dr Halal
#27 TH17
3-starred #3 Dr.Med.DenRasen
After 2 failed attempts:
SenorGato (2*), who am i (2*)
The Godfather
#4 TH18
3-starred #5 LubiAs
After 3 failed attempts:
Shifty (2*), BOOM! (1*), Dr Halal (1*)
LilWeezyAna
#3 TH18
3-starred #10 leon
After 2 failed attempts:
nirvana (2*), Ataraxy Queen (2*)
AlbaMana
#18 TH18
3-starred #16 Loubex
After 2 failed attempts:
Ndnolan (2*), Anika (2*)
TopShelf
#21 TH18
3-starred #20 ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃
After 5 failed attempts:
Shady (2*), AlbaMana (2*), Gus Vats (1*), Loki (2*), Shifty (2*)
Root Cause Analysis
The loss stems from a cascading coordination failure in the top section (#1-10), which averaged only 4.0 stars per player. Because top attackers struggled, lower Town Halls were forced into TH mismatches against TH18s, leading to massive attack drains like the 7-attack pileup on #15 and a 6-attack pileup on #20 (which TopShelf barely salvaged). Compounding this attack economy crisis was Anthony's missed attack and a botched cleanup on Base #9, leaving highly vulnerable bases standing in a tight 3-star loss.
What-If Scenarios
If Anthony had used his missed attack to clean up Base #9 (which Anika left at 99%), and if the clan hadn't burned 6 subsequent attacks failing to finish Base #15 after Shady's initial 94%, Sitting Ducks would have easily closed the 3-star gap to tie or win.
Actionable Takeaways
- ‣ Implement a strict cutoff for pileups: after 3 failed attempts on bases like #15, leadership must reassign targets to prevent draining the attack economy.
- ‣ Hold top section players accountable for missed attacks and poor performance; Anthony's missed attack and Thor's 2-star contribution were fatal in a 3-star loss.
- ‣ Stop allowing lower Town Halls (Shady, Loki, Dr Haram) to repeatedly hit max TH18s, as this resulted in 7 failed 3-star attempts that wasted valuable attacks.
- ‣ Review cleanup protocols: Ataraxy Queen regressing to a 92% 1-star on Base #9 after Anika's 99% shows a need for safer, guaranteed cleanup strategies.
- ‣ Study Dr Halal's incredible clutch performance (punching up to 3-star TH18 #3 after two TH18s failed) as a model for how lower THs can strategically save top-tier attacks.
Attacking Down (1)
Shifty
(#15)
attacked #20
— 5 positions below
♻ Cleanup Attacks (1)
Ndnolan
(#11)
cleaned up #16
— mirror handled, 5 positions below
Member Performance
⬇ Attacking down|
♻ Cleanup attack|
★ Atk 1
★ Atk 2
| # | Player | TH | Attacks | Stars | Targets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | SenorGato | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
68%
|
#1 TH18 | #3 TH18 |
| 2 | who am i | 18 | 2/2 |
78%
★★★
|
★★★
72%
|
#2 TH18 | #3 TH18 |
| 3 | LilWeezyAna | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#4 TH18 | #10 TH18 |
| 4 | The Godfather | 18 | 2/2 |
97%
★★★
|
★★★
|
#4 TH18 | #5 TH18 |
| 5 | BOOM! | 18 | 2/2 |
83%
★★★
|
★★★
|
#5 TH18 | #8 TH18 |
| 6 | Thor | 18 | 2/2 |
80%
★★★
|
★★★
82%
|
#13 TH18 | #15 TH18 |
| 7 | Reptar | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#7 TH18 | #6 TH18 |
| 8 | Anthony | 18 | 1/2 |
75%
★★★
|
missed
|
#8 TH18 |
| 9 | Ataraxy Queen | 18 | 2/2 |
92%
★★★
|
★★★
92%
|
#10 TH18 | #9 TH18 |
| 10 | nirvana | 18 | 2/2 |
93%
★★★
|
★★★
74%
|
#10 TH18 | #9 TH18 |
| 11 | Ndnolan | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
68%
|
#11 TH18 | ♻ #16 TH18 |
| 12 | WARLORD | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#12 TH18 | #2 TH18 |
| 13 | ManaAlba | 18 | 2/2 |
66%
★★★
|
★★★
91%
|
#15 TH18 | #13 TH18 |
| 14 | Slaughterhouse | 18 | 2/2 |
23%
★★★
|
★★★
77%
|
#14 TH18 | #13 TH18 |
| 15 | Shifty | 18 | 2/2 |
95%
★★★
|
★★★
62%
|
⬇ #20 TH18 | #5 TH18 |
| 16 | Anika | 18 | 2/2 |
99%
★★★
|
★★★
99%
|
#16 TH18 | #9 TH18 |
| 17 | Dark Sparks | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#17 TH18 | #14 TH18 |
| 18 | AlbaMana | 18 | 2/2 |
94%
★★★
|
★★★
|
#20 TH18 | #16 TH18 |
| 19 | igo | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#19 TH18 | #18 TH18 |
| 20 | Gus Vats | 18 | 2/2 |
89%
★★★
|
★★★
82%
|
#20 TH18 | #15 TH18 |
| 21 | TopShelf | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
79%
|
#20 TH18 | #15 TH18 |
| 22 | SlapShot | 18 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#22 TH18 | #21 TH18 |
| 23 | KingSlapShot | 17 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#23 TH17 | #24 TH18 |
| 24 | Loki | 17 | 2/2 |
63%
★★★
|
★★★
90%
|
#15 TH18 | #20 TH18 |
| 25 | Shady | 17 | 2/2 |
83%
★★★
|
★★★
94%
|
#20 TH18 | #15 TH18 |
| 26 | Megs☘️ | 17 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#25 TH17 | #26 TH16 |
| 27 | Dr Halal | 17 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
78%
|
#3 TH18 | #5 TH18 |
| 28 | MEGHA | 16 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#27 TH15 | ▼ #28 TH11 |
| 29 | DEADLYFEET | 14 | 2/2 |
★★★
|
★★★
|
#29 TH11 | #30 TH10 |
| 30 | Dr Haram | 16 | 2/2 |
91%
★★★
|
★★★
80%
|
#15 TH18 | #13 TH18 |
Attacks
| Order | Attacker | TH | Atk# | Defender | Def# | Def TH | Stars | Destruction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Reptar | 18 | 1st | !!!OLE!!! | 7 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 4 | Reptar | 18 | 2nd | Lord-Zyx | 6 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 5 | Ndnolan | 18 | 1st | Lord-Zyx3 | 11 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 7 | Ndnolan ♻ | 18 | 2nd | Loubex | 16 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 68% |
| 9 | igo | 18 | 1st | Gott | 19 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 10 | igo | 18 | 2nd | TestoAzubi | 18 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 11 | SenorGato | 18 | 1st | :D | 1 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 12 | Slaughterhouse | 18 | 1st | xSh12o | 14 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 23% |
| 13 | Anika | 18 | 1st | Loubex | 16 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 99% |
| 14 | The Godfather | 18 | 1st | Audi | 4 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 97% |
| 15 | who am i | 18 | 1st | NF❄️eZ0phat | 2 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 78% |
| 16 | nirvana | 18 | 1st | leon | 10 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 93% |
| 17 | nirvana | 18 | 2nd | ProbablyS1M0N | 9 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 74% |
| 18 | WARLORD | 18 | 1st | Lord-Zyx2 | 12 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 19 | KingSlapShot | 17 | 1st | :D Jr | 23 | 17 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 20 | SlapShot | 18 | 1st | xXMiniVegetaXx | 22 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 21 | KingSlapShot | 17 | 2nd | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₄ | 24 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 22 | SlapShot | 18 | 2nd | NF❄️eZ0phat-II | 21 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 23 | SenorGato | 18 | 2nd | Dr.Med.DenRasen | 3 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 68% |
| 24 | Megs☘️ | 17 | 1st | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₅ | 25 | 17 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 25 | Megs☘️ | 17 | 2nd | xmrc〆₂ | 26 | 16 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 26 | Dark Sparks | 18 | 1st | Spacko | 17 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 27 | Dark Sparks | 18 | 2nd | xSh12o | 14 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 28 | Shady | 17 | 1st | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃ | 20 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 83% |
| 29 | Shady | 17 | 2nd | ChuubChuup | 15 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 94% |
| 32 | MEGHA | 16 | 1st | :D mini Jr | 27 | 15 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 33 | MEGHA | 16 | 2nd | :D 4 | 28 | 11 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 34 | Anika | 18 | 2nd | ProbablyS1M0N | 9 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 99% |
| 37 | AlbaMana | 18 | 1st | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃ | 20 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 94% |
| 38 | AlbaMana | 18 | 2nd | Loubex | 16 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 39 | Slaughterhouse | 18 | 2nd | Muffin | 13 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 77% |
| 40 | Gus Vats | 18 | 1st | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃ | 20 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 89% |
| 41 | Gus Vats | 18 | 2nd | ChuubChuup | 15 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 82% |
| 46 | DEADLYFEET | 14 | 1st | :D 5 | 29 | 11 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 47 | DEADLYFEET | 14 | 2nd | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₇ | 30 | 10 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 48 | Loki | 17 | 1st | ChuubChuup | 15 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 63% |
| 49 | Loki | 17 | 2nd | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃ | 20 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 90% |
| 51 | Anthony | 18 | 1st | NF❄️Mathis | 8 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 75% |
| 61 | Shifty ⬇ | 18 | 1st | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃ | 20 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 95% |
| 62 | Shifty | 18 | 2nd | LubiAs | 5 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 62% |
| 63 | who am i | 18 | 2nd | Dr.Med.DenRasen | 3 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 72% |
| 64 | TopShelf | 18 | 1st | ⁱᵃᵐBosca₃ | 20 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 65 | TopShelf | 18 | 2nd | ChuubChuup | 15 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 79% |
| 68 | Ataraxy Queen | 18 | 1st | leon | 10 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 92% |
| 70 | Ataraxy Queen | 18 | 2nd | ProbablyS1M0N | 9 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 92% |
| 78 | Thor | 18 | 1st | Muffin | 13 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 80% |
| 79 | Thor | 18 | 2nd | ChuubChuup | 15 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 82% |
| 80 | BOOM! | 18 | 1st | LubiAs | 5 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 83% |
| 81 | BOOM! | 18 | 2nd | NF❄️Mathis | 8 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 82 | WARLORD | 18 | 2nd | NF❄️eZ0phat | 2 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 99 | Dr Haram | 16 | 1st | ChuubChuup | 15 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 91% |
| 101 | Dr Haram | 16 | 2nd | Muffin | 13 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 80% |
| 102 | Dr Halal | 17 | 1st | Dr.Med.DenRasen | 3 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 103 | ManaAlba | 18 | 1st | ChuubChuup | 15 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 66% |
| 104 | Dr Halal | 17 | 2nd | LubiAs | 5 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 78% |
| 108 | ManaAlba | 18 | 2nd | Muffin | 13 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 91% |
| 111 | The Godfather | 18 | 2nd | LubiAs | 5 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 112 | LilWeezyAna | 18 | 1st | Audi | 4 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |
| 113 | LilWeezyAna | 18 | 2nd | leon | 10 | 18 | ★ ★ ★ | 100% |