Sitting Ducks vs #clan

30v30
90 - 86
Victory

War Analysis

0 bases not 3-starred

Executive Summary

Sitting Ducks secured a perfect 90-86 victory, achieving 100% destruction against #clan. While the Bottom section (#21-30) delivered a flawless performance to anchor the win, the war was marred by severe negligence where three players attacked Base #1 after it was already 3-starred, wasting 5% of our total offensive output.

Section Performance

top #1-10 10 players
4.3 avg stars
43/60 possible stars
bottom #21-30 10 players
5.0 avg stars
50/60 possible stars
middle #11-20 10 players
3.9 avg stars
39/60 possible stars

Pileup Bases

#1 Winston received 4 attacks (7% of total) — 3-starred
#3 Stallion received 4 attacks (7% of total) — 3-starred
#11 max received 3 attacks (6% of total) — 3-starred
#12 KoReAniTo/1 received 5 attacks (9% of total) — 3-starred
#17 Heyuan received 3 attacks (6% of total) — 3-starred

Under-Performers

Ataraxy Queen #11 TH18 1* vs 3.9 avg
Tóâ #28 TH17 1* vs 5.0 avg
Tgeland 2.0 #19 TH17 2* vs 3.9 avg
whowehatetobe #30 TH10 3* vs 5.0 avg

Missed Attacks (6)

The Godfather #4 TH18 1/2
Smooth Criminal #9 TH18 1/2
BigDaddyDyl #10 TH18 0/2
Ataraxy Queen #11 TH18 1/2
Tóâ #28 TH17 1/2

MVPs (ranked by net stars + clutch bonus)

Megs☘️
#27 TH16
6 net stars
6 raw stars — #26: 3* 100%, #27: 3* 100%
SenorGato
#2 TH18
6 net stars
6 raw stars — #2: 3* 100%, #4: 3* 100%
SlapShot
#14 TH17
6 net stars
6 raw stars — #14: 3* 100%, #15: 3* 100%

Clutch Attacks (3-starred after 2+ prior failed attempts)

Dark Sparks #21 TH17 3-starred #1 Winston
After 2 failed attempts: ManaAlba (2*), igo (2*)
BOOM! #5 TH18 3-starred #3 Stallion
After 3 failed attempts: LilWeezyAna (2*), Tgeland 2.0 (1*), who am i (2*)
Anthony #8 TH18 3-starred #11 max
After 2 failed attempts: WARLORD (1*), Dark Sparks (2*)
Smooth Criminal #9 TH18 3-starred #12 KoReAniTo/1
After 4 failed attempts: ManaAlba (2*), PRO⚡️EMPEROR (1*), Ataraxy Queen (1*), Tóâ (1*)
PRO⚡️EMPEROR #16 TH18 3-starred #17 Heyuan
After 2 failed attempts: AlbaMana (2*), ++Shifty++ (2*)

Root Cause Analysis

The perfect score masked a chaotic chain reaction starting with 6 missed attacks from top TH18s like BigDaddyDyl and The Godfather. This forced TH17s (e.g., ManaAlba, WARLORD) to attempt low-percentage mismatch attacks against TH18s, resulting in pileups on bases #11 and #12 that required clutch saves from Smooth Criminal and Anthony to close out.

What-If Scenarios

Had Smooth Criminal not secured the 3-star on Base #12 after four consecutive failures by teammates, we would have finished with 89 stars. Furthermore, if the enemy clan had also posted a perfect war, our wasted attacks on the already-cleared Base #1 would have destroyed our average attack duration tie-breaker.

Actionable Takeaways

  • **Map Awareness Failure:** ManaAlba, igo, and Dark Sparks must verify target status before attacking; wasting three attacks on Base #1 (attacks 92, 107, 109) when LilWeezyAna cleared it at attack #20 is unacceptable.
  • **Top-End Accountability:** BigDaddyDyl (0/2) and The Godfather (1/2) missing attacks directly forced TH17s into 10 separate mismatch hits against TH18s; top bases must clear their weight to protect the middle section.
  • **Pileup Protocol:** Base #12 absorbed 5 attacks; future bases surviving 3 hits must be frozen and assigned to a specific closer like BOOM! or SenorGato immediately to prevent further wasted attempts.
  • **Section Reliance:** The Middle section (avg 3.9 stars) is a liability; players like Ataraxy Queen and Tgeland 2.0 need to improve consistency so we do not rely solely on the Bottom section (Megs☘️, KingSlapShot) to carry the war.

♻ Cleanup Attacks (1)

=(Shifty)= (#23) cleaned up #28mirror handled, 5 positions below

Member Performance

Cleanup attack| Atk 1 Atk 2
# Player TH Attacks Stars Targets
1 who am i 18 2/2
89% | 94%
#3 TH18 | #9 TH18
2 SenorGato 18 2/2
|
#2 TH18 | #4 TH18
3 LilWeezyAna 18 2/2
99% |
#3 TH18 | #1 TH18
4 The Godfather 18 1/2
| missed
#5 TH18
5 BOOM! 18 2/2
|
#3 TH18 | #9 TH18
6 C-Dub 18 2/2
|
#6 TH18 | #7 TH18
7 Reptar 18 2/2
70% |
#7 TH18 | #8 TH18
8 Anthony 18 2/2
|
#10 TH18 | #11 TH18
9 Smooth Criminal 18 1/2
| missed
#12 TH18
10 BigDaddyDyl 18 0/2 no attacks
11 Ataraxy Queen 18 1/2
90% | missed
#12 TH18
12 ManaAlba 17 2/2
98% | 57%
#12 TH18 | #1 TH18
13 igo 17 2/2
65% | 73%
#1 TH18 | #2 TH18
14 SlapShot 17 2/2
|
#14 TH18 | #15 TH17
15 ++Shifty++ 17 2/2
87% |
#17 TH17 | #13 TH18
16 PRO⚡️EMPEROR 18 2/2
| 66%
#17 TH17 | #12 TH18
17 AlbaMana 17 2/2
78% |
#17 TH17 | #16 TH17
18 WARLORD 17 2/2
68% | 91%
#11 TH18 | #10 TH18
19 Tgeland 2.0 17 2/2
74% | 80%
#16 TH17 | #3 TH18
20 Ritz 17 2/2
|
#20 TH17 | #14 TH18
21 Dark Sparks 17 2/2
82% |
#11 TH18 | #1 TH18
22 TopShelf 17 2/2
|
#22 TH17 | #23 TH16
23 =(Shifty)= 16 2/2
|
♻ #28 TH15 | #18 TH17
24 ⚜Who Dat⚜ 16 2/2
|
#21 TH17 | #20 TH17
25 DeevesMcQueen 16 2/2
76% |
#23 TH16 | #25 TH16
26 KingSlapShot 17 2/2
|
#24 TH17 | #19 TH17
27 Megs☘️ 16 2/2
|
#26 TH16 | #27 TH15
28 Tóâ 17 1/2
55% | missed
#12 TH18
29 Dr Halal 14 2/2
|
#30 TH10 | #29 TH13
30 whowehatetobe 10 2/2
64% | 35%
#30 TH10 | #29 TH13

Attacks

Order Attacker TH Atk# Defender Def# Def TH Stars Destruction
1 Megs☘️ 16 1st powerclub77 26 16 100%
2 whowehatetobe 10 1st Brightlee 30 10 64%
3 whowehatetobe 10 2nd Chris 2 29 13 35%
4 Megs☘️ 16 2nd JTDestroyer 27 15 100%
5 DeevesMcQueen 16 1st GingerusMaximus 23 16 76%
6 SenorGato 18 1st Jackie Y 2 18 100%
7 TopShelf 17 1st IGN(SenSei?) 22 17 100%
8 TopShelf 17 2nd GingerusMaximus 23 16 100%
9 DeevesMcQueen 16 2nd MiSan7 25 16 100%
10 SlapShot 17 1st Bon_Clay_No.17 14 18 100%
11 KingSlapShot 17 1st AMiSan 24 17 100%
14 ⚜Who Dat⚜ 16 1st ♡XanDeR♡ 21 17 100%
16 LilWeezyAna 18 1st Stallion 3 18 99%
19 ⚜Who Dat⚜ 16 2nd ThugCity:) 20 17 100%
20 LilWeezyAna 18 2nd Winston 1 18 100%
22 Dr Halal 14 1st Brightlee 30 10 100%
23 Dr Halal 14 2nd Chris 2 29 13 100%
26 Reptar 18 1st HASEEB DHONI 7 18 70%
27 SlapShot 17 2nd Orange_fox 15 17 100%
29 Reptar 18 2nd chris 8 18 100%
31 KingSlapShot 17 2nd Ace Jules 19 17 100%
33 C-Dub 18 1st pancake eyes 6 18 100%
34 C-Dub 18 2nd HASEEB DHONI 7 18 100%
40 SenorGato 18 2nd thebigchez 4 18 100%
44 The Godfather 18 1st Mikkelmania 5 18 100%
51 Tgeland 2.0 17 1st Pandi 16 17 74%
52 AlbaMana 17 1st Heyuan 17 17 78%
54 AlbaMana 17 2nd Pandi 16 17 100%
55 ManaAlba 17 1st KoReAniTo/1 12 18 98%
56 =(Shifty)= 16 1st space 28 15 100%
57 =(Shifty)= 16 2nd Bousie 18 17 100%
58 ++Shifty++ 17 1st Heyuan 17 17 87%
59 ++Shifty++ 17 2nd KEN13 13 18 100%
61 PRO⚡️EMPEROR 18 1st Heyuan 17 17 100%
63 PRO⚡️EMPEROR 18 2nd KoReAniTo/1 12 18 66%
64 WARLORD 17 1st max 11 18 68%
65 WARLORD 17 2nd Syrup Lips 10 18 91%
67 Dark Sparks 17 1st max 11 18 82%
69 Tgeland 2.0 17 2nd Stallion 3 18 80%
74 who am i 18 1st Stallion 3 18 89%
75 who am i 18 2nd Mikkelmayhem 9 18 94%
76 BOOM! 18 1st Stallion 3 18 100%
77 BOOM! 18 2nd Mikkelmayhem 9 18 100%
84 Anthony 18 1st Syrup Lips 10 18 100%
85 Anthony 18 2nd max 11 18 100%
92 ManaAlba 17 2nd Winston 1 18 57%
96 Ataraxy Queen 18 1st KoReAniTo/1 12 18 90%
97 Tóâ 17 1st KoReAniTo/1 12 18 55%
99 Smooth Criminal 18 1st KoReAniTo/1 12 18 100%
103 Ritz 17 1st ThugCity:) 20 17 100%
104 Ritz 17 2nd Bon_Clay_No.17 14 18 100%
107 igo 17 1st Winston 1 18 65%
108 igo 17 2nd Jackie Y 2 18 73%
109 Dark Sparks 17 2nd Winston 1 18 100%